The authors make the case that excessive reliance on outside consultants with extractive business models is stunting state capacity and undermining democratic accountability. They cite, for example, a British Cabinet officer who charged that outsourcing government functions not only provides poor value for money but also “infantilizes the civil service by depriving our brightest people of opportunities to work on some of the most challenging, fulfilling, and crunchy issues.”
It’s not a joyous read, but it is provocative, and I think that’s what we need right now. Leaders across the public sector and wider economy are stretched, and the questions about when to buy in advice and when to build our own capability are very live. Busyness and complicated authorising environments leave little bandwidth for the deep thinking that surfaces and tests unseen assumptions, habitual thinking, and, in some cases, learned helplessness.
Four key themes:
1. A hollowed-out state. The authors offer that decades of outsourcing under “New Public Management” have removed the learning-by-doing that builds capability. They argue that the civil service becomes deskilled and dependent (“…hollowed out and timid…”), needing another consultant to solve the next problem.
2. Rent vs. value creation. Consultancies present themselves as objective experts, but the authors argue that some charge substantial fees for standardised approaches and create ongoing client dependency. In these cases, revenue may come less from delivering new value and more from securing repeat work through that dependency
3. Who carries the blame? Leaders may hire prestigious firms to rubber-stamp decisions or absorb political risk. When initiatives fail, accountability is diluted or shielded behind opaque, proprietary commercial boundaries, and the blame absorbed by an ephemeral consulting team.
4. Playing both sides. A core reflection in the book is how consultancies act on conflicting mandates. For instance, a firm might simultaneously advise a government agency on meeting stringent carbon-neutral targets, while pulling in massive fees from major fossil fuel corporations to optimise their oil production.
Where I’d push back. The book is a critique of extractive business models, not of all external advice. Outside expertise can add real value: speed, independence, specialist skills, and fresh perspective.
The question isn’t whether to use it, but whether it leaves you more capable than before.
WBL’s position. As a leadership development consultancy ourselves, this observation of the history and reputations of consulting made us uncomfortable, and that is exactly why we’re sharing it. Make a difference is one of WBL’s three key values. Our aim is to support vs. substitute the capability of your organisation and leaders. It’s the thinking behind our recent Enabling Leader-Led Growth kōrero and the goal of WBL Self-Service.
So what?
-
For Leaders: What capability are you outsourcing that you may need to be building?
-
For People & Culture: How do you make sure external support leaves your organisation and people stronger vs. more dependent?
- Try this: Look back at your last few external engagements and ask: “What did we keep when they left?” “How did we grow future capability and organisational resilience?”